our menu

Fresh Ingredients. Killer Comfort Food.

High-end, local ingredients. Everything is made from scratch.

our menu

Known for the COLDEST BEER in town!

James Spears opened the original building at 19 west main street in 1812. At the time, the Spears Tavern, as it was called, had two entrances, two dining rooms and ten guest rooms for stagecoach passengers and other visitors to North Penfield as it was then called. In 1849, Alexis Russell ran the inn as The Russell House, later renting accommodations to adults especially to those who objected to patronizing a hotel that served liquor like the Webster Hotel. When the Russell House closed the west end of the building was rented to Dr. James E. Smith, who in 1893 became Webster's first resident veterinarian.  Since then, many people have owned and operated the building at 19 West Main Street. Charles Steve reopened the hotel in 1904. Mae DeField operated the DeField Hotel for many years at the same location. In 1936 the Stage Coach Inn opened under the ownership of Mr. and Mrs. McGuire and subsequently went through many owners until Anthony Stolt bought the property in1950/ Mr. Stolt operated the inn even through the devastating fire on February 16th, 1969, when the building was completely razed. The structure as it is today opened in September of 1969. In December 1983, four local businesses men bought the Coach. Charles Basch, John Harten, Ralph Ruoff, and Richard Sippel operated the restaurant with Larry Panepinto until November 16th, 1988 when the doors again closed. Marti Sierk reopened the building in 1990 as the Webster Village Inn, a formal restaurant and bar. She later decided the village needed a more casual atmosphere and renovated the inside to make it that way. In 1991 she reestablished the business as the Coach, a reflection of the past existence as the Stage Coach Inn. The Sierk family has operated it ever since.